Saturday, July 17, 2010

30 lawmakers to file amicus brief in defense of AZ SB 1070

The first half of this Politico article is dedicated to the Federal Government and others like Grijalva (D-AZ), who is calling for a boycott of his own state, and Gutierrez (D-Ill), who is just another cog in the Chicago politcal machine.  These are open borders advocates and members of La Raza who are against AZ SB 1070, of course.  But scroll down to the bottom of the article and find that 30 lawmakers have signed onto an amicus brief to be filed ins upport of AZ SB 1070.
After the American Civil Liberties Union filed suit in May to reverse the Arizona law, Rep. Tom McClintock (R-Calif.) this week drafted 17 House colleagues to become party to a friend of the court brief backing the state.

Most of the GOP’s participation and focus, however, has centered on the Justice Department suit.

This week, two border state congressmen, Rep. Brian Bilbray (R-Calif.) and Rep. Trent Franks (R-Ariz.), have been collecting signatures from the nearly 100 members of the Immigration Reform Caucus for an amicus brief that will be filed in support of Arizona on Monday. By Thursday, about 30 lawmakers had signed on.

“Arizona has not created a counter policy. It is completely parallel and consistent with federal law,” said Bilbray, the caucus chairman who represents a San Diego-area district. “All [Arizona has] done is taken the federal law, moderated it, actually put more protection against (racial) profiling.”

DeMint and Vitter, meanwhile, are using the congressional amendment process to try to undermine the Justice Department. The two introduced an appropriations amendment to a small business bill that would ban federal funds from being used in any lawsuit seeking to overturn provisions of Arizona’s strict immigration law. The bill is set to be debated on the floor next week.

Vitter declined to comment Thursday but noted in a statement that polls show a majority of Americans reject the Justice Department suit.

“The state of Arizona is simply taking responsibility for a problem that the federal government has neglected for years, but Washington’s only response is to oppose these new enforcement efforts and take them to court,” Vitter said. “The Obama administration should not use taxpayers’ money to pay for these lawsuits that the American people overwhelmingly oppose.”

Illegal Immigrants and their impact on Maricopa County Arizona

Illegal Immigrants in Maricopa County Arizona.  That is the name of a report i found at icarizona which reposted this September 2008 report on Illegal Immigration from then Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas (Dowloand PDF).  It seems icarizona's purpose is to illustrate the dramatic difference between Andrew Thomas and the current Maricopa County Attorney.

My purpose in posting it here is entirely different.  I want to help educate the rest of the world on the state of affairs in Phoenix, in Maricopa County, and in Arizona in general.  The document is heavily footnoted and linked but the new County Attorney has moved some of the documents.  A secondary purpose is to address those who whine (yes, i said whine!) that we are focusing on the Southern border rather than the Northern border.  The implication is that we are racist and focusing on the brown people.  That claim is ludicrous since the Southern border is where the vast majority of the problem is occurring.  The report shows that claim to be what it is - misguided racism on the part of those making the claim.

Some highlights:
Executive Summary
  • In June 2008, the Arizona prison system reported a population of 5,173 Mexican Nationals.
  • In 2004, the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) estimated the annual cost of incarcerating illegal immigrants in Arizona prisons and jails equal to $80 million. (2008 estimate is $114 million annually)
  • Law enforcement and criminal prosecutions linked to illegal immigration costs the Arizona border counties of Cochise, Pima, Santa Cruz, and Yuma millions annually. A recent study estimates that these four border counties in Arizona costs were $26.6 million in 2006.
  • In 2005, the Government Accounting Office (GAO) conducted sample studies using a pool of more than 55,000 illegal immigrants
    • The group was arrested a total of 459, 614 times, averaging 8 arrests per illegal immigrant
    • They were arrested for a total of 700,000 offenses, averaging 13 offenses per illegal immigrant.
    • 12% of these offenses were violent offenses like robbery, assualt, and sex-related crimes.
    • 15% were propety related offenses like burglary, larceny-theft, motor vehicle theft and property damage.
    • 45% were drug or immigration offenses
    • the remaining 28% were for other offenses (traffic, DUI, fraud, weapons violations, obstruction of justiced, etc)
    • 80% of all arrests occurred in three states: California, Texas, and Arizona. (Yes, Peggy, Arizona is indeed a border state just like Texas! - K)
Illegal Immigration Statistics

Arizona
...the U.S. Department of Homeland Security reported the state's illegal immigrant population to be 530,000.  This is a 62% increase from 330,000 they reported in 2000.  In 2007, the Center for Immigration Studies reported Arizona's illegal immigrant population to be 9% (579,000 people).  A study from the Udall Center for Studies in Public Policy reports the non-citizen immigrant population in Arizona to be 619,800 people.... a reasonable average of these studies is that approximately 9% of Arizona's population is comprised of illegal immigrants.

Maricopa County
...An analysis has found that in 2007 18.7% of defendants sentenced in Maricopa County Superior Court were illegal immigrants.....total percentage of illegal immigrant defendants sentenced for felonies in Maricopa County Superior court is 21.8%
Click this picture.  Red is the % of that crime committed by illegals.  Blue is the % of those crimes by by people who are legally present in this country.



Illegal Immigration's Impact on Maricopa County Crime
...16.5% of violent crimes can be linked to illegal immigrants.  In 2007, 18,100 violent crimes were reported to Maricopa County law enforcement....2,973... committed by illegal immigrants....the financial hardship imposed on Maricopa County citizens totaled approximately $59 million dollars in 2007.
...18.5% of poperty crimes can be linked to illegal immigrants.  In 2007, 165,743 property crimes were reported to Maricopa County law enforcement.... 6,684...committed by illegal immigrants....the financial hardship imposted on Maricopa County citizens in property alone totaled approximately $24 million in 2007.

Illegal Immigration Legislation
2005
Senate Bill 1372 made human smuggling a crime...Class 4 felony punishable with up to three years in prison.
2006
Proposition 100... prohibits bail for any person who is charged with a serious felony offense and who is unlawfully in the U.S.  As a result illegal immigrants who are charged with serious felonies can no longer be released.
2007
Legal Arizona Workers Act (LAWA)...allows a court to suspend or revoke the business license of employers found to have knowlingly hired illegal workers.  The bill also strengthened the State's ID theft laws against persons who use false documents to obtain employement.
2008
LAWA amendments to punish an employer who knowingly accepts false identification from an applicant for employment.
2010 (not from the 2008 report, of course), SB 1070 was passed codifying into state law that state, county, and local law enforcement are required to enforce federal law.

Friday, July 16, 2010

KeepAZSafe update and Border Sheriffs need defense help too

Arizona County Sheriffs (all of them) are being sued pre-emptively by the ACLU before they even begin to enforce SB1070.  Local news says the lawsuit alleges future racial profiling.

The population of Arizona is about 6 million which means Arizona is less than 2% of the population of the USA.  Also, about 5 million of the 6 million residents of Arizona live in the Phoenix metropolitan area in Maricopa County.  That means that the vast majority of the rest of the state is rural.  These rural counties have low population and thus do not have the tax base to defend against these ridiculous lawsuits.

I know many people have donated to the state defense fund, Keep AZ Safe, and I personally thank you.  You have no idea what it means to me because I cannot put it into words.  As of today, over 100,000 people from all over the country (incuding Puerto Rico) have donated approximately $1.2 million.

If you could please help the Border Sheriffs in their defense as well.  Any size donation is appreciated. 

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

MI AG Cox files amicus brief in support of AZ SB 1070 along with 8 other states

Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox filed an amicus brief in support of AZ SB 1070.   He is joined by eight states, and one U.S. Territory Florida, Alabama, Nebraska, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Virginia, and the Northern Mariana Islands.


Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox today announced that he has filed an amicus brief this afternoon in federal court supporting Arizona's common-sense immigration law against a lawsuit filed by the Obama administration. Michigan is the lead state backing Arizona before the court and is joined by eight states, and one U.S. Territory Florida, Alabama, Nebraska, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Virginia, and the Northern Mariana Islands.

"Arizona, Michigan and every other state have the authority to enforce immigration laws, and it is appalling to see President Obama use taxpayer dollars to stop a state's efforts to protect its own borders," said Cox. "My mother was a legal immigrant who faithfully carried her green card with her for years before gaining citizenship - it certainly is not too much to ask legal immigrants to do the same today."

...

The amicus brief, filed Wednesday afternoon in the United States District Court for the District of Arizona, defends the States' authority to concurrently enforce federal immigration laws, especially in light of the selective and even lack of enforcement of those laws by the Obama administration. Under the current situation, the States have lost control over their borders and are left to guess at the reality of the law.

Common Sense Arizona-style reform in Florida?

I hope they get a vote on these bills in Florida.  If that skinny traitorous way-too-tanned freak Crist vetoes them, then Rubio will get even more votes for the Senate.

Arizona-style immigration bills filed for possible consideration next week

TAMPA - The first bills filed for next week's special legislative session have nothing to do with what Gov. Charlie Crist called lawmakers together to discuss.

Crist wants the Legislature to approve a constitutional amendment to ban offshore oil drilling, but state Rep. Kevin Ambler, a Tampa Republican running for the state Senate, has filed three bills targeting illegal immigrants in Florida.

The bills would:

• Enable law enforcement officials to check on a person's residency status during routine stops or arrests, using the federal E-Verify program created for employers to check on a worker's status.

• Require proof of legal residency or citizenship for receipt of certain public benefits. The prohibition would not include emergency or crisis care or immunizations for communicable diseases.

• Prohibit a person from working for any state agency if he can't prove he is a legal resident or citizen. The proposal doesn't include any measures to penalize private employers who hire illegal immigrants.

Joining Ambler in his proposal is state Sen. Paula Dockery, R-Lakeland, though she has yet to file her bills. Senate rules prevent her from proposing anything beyond the issue Crist called lawmakers together to consider in response to the Deepwater Horizon oil gusher in the Gulf of Mexico.

Unless Crist expands his call, two-thirds of the House and Senate members will have to approve addressing outside issues.

Dockery and Ambler sent a letter to Senate President Jeff Atwater and House Speaker Larry Cretul today asking them to back expanding the call to include the immigration bills.

It said the bills would "protect the economic security and public safety of our great state. With communities all over the state threatened by criminals who violate our immigration laws, and a federal bureaucracy unable to fulfill its most basic responsibility, the Florida Legislature has an opportunity to make a difference now."

Both Dockery and Ambler describe the bills as "common sense" Arizona-style reform. One key difference is giving law enforcement officers access to E-Verify, a federal, Internet-based system that allows someone to instantly check on whether someone is legally in the United States.

It was created for employers, but it should also be made available to public officials, Ambler said.

Ambler said that about 900,000 illegal immigrants live in Florida. Only Texas and California have more.

Both he and Dockery emphasized the high cost of the 5,667 illegal immigrants now in Florida's prisons. But their proposals would do nothing to change that, because deportation is a federal responsibility. They might even increase the number of jailed immigrants as law enforcement officers arrest those who can't prove they are legal.

Three Quarters of Americans support AZ SB 1070

(via Stop the ACLU)

Poll: Support for Arizona Immigration Law Hits 57 Percent

While the headline is not a lie, it does fail to tell the whole truth because it fails to note the additional 17% who say the law doesn't go far enough.

I can do math.  57+17=74.

Monday, July 12, 2010

Other Immigration Lawsuits

I looked up some other immigration lawsuits which I have heard mentioned as precedent for an ultimate ruling in Arizona's favor in the federal lawsuit.  I have not analyzed them yet and don't know that any analysis that I could do would be of any value to anyone but here they are:

MUEHLER et al. v. MENA

Estrada v. State of Rhode Island

Undocumented Migrant Waste Website

I discovered the Undocumented Migrant Waste Website developed by the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality in partnership with the University of Arizona School of Geography and Development, the Environmental Protection Agency Border 2012 Program through the Border Environment Cooperation Commission, and the Bureau of Land Management.  It's stated purpose is to facilitate the coordination of Arizona Border staekholders in the mitigation of undocumented migrant waste by providing a central location for resources about cleanups.

Note this is not created or funded by private individuals but by state and federal agencies and commisions and such indicating this is a problem long recognized by government at all levels but currently denied.



I remind you all that this extends far into the heart of Arizona as documented by many others and noted here recently.

Friday, July 09, 2010

Salt Lake City, UT votes down boycott of Arizona

The Salt Lake City Council and Mayor Ralph Becker reject Arizona boycott! 

Salt Lake City Mayor Ralph Becker and city council members have rejected the idea of boycotting the state of Arizona. "The mayor never wanted to go down that road," said chief of staff David Everett.

Council Chairman J.T. Martin said the notion was raised in the council meeting last week but quickly dropped as members didn't even want to discuss the issue. With Utah spending about $21 million per year doing business with Arizona companies, an economic boycott would have a significant effect on the state's economy.
Read it all.  It seems that Mayor Becker is still stinging from the boycott of Utah and all things possibly Mormon after California's Proposition 8.
I phoned them and they said they were getting quite a few calls and alot of emails.  Let them know you support them!

Contact them here:

The Salt Lake City Council Welcomes Your Comments

Email: council.comments@slcgov.com

Write: Salt Lake City Council
451 S. State Street, Room 304
P.O. Box 145476
Salt Lake City, UT 84114-5476
(please include P.O. Box to ensure delivery)

Phone: (801) 535-7600
Fax: (801) 535-7651

24- Hr Comment Line: (801) 535-7654

Rhode Island Illegal Immigration Control Order

March 27, 2008 Rhode Island Governor issued Executive Order 08-01 (pdf) entitled Illegal Immigration Control Order which resulted in the state of Rhode Island law enforcement doing exactly the same thing that AZ SB 1070 does for Arizona law enforcement.  So, why isn't the Federal Government suing Rhode Island?  And, even more important, why isn't Rhode Island officially filing an amicus brief on the side of AZ?



EXECUTIVE ORDER
08-01
March 27, 2008
ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION CONTROL ORDER

WHEREAS, most Rhode Islanders and most Americans are descendants of immigrants from all regions of the world and Rhode Island continues to welcome new immigrants who legally seek the opportunities that the state, its economy, and its resources offer; and
WHEREAS, Congress and the President have been unable to resolve the problem of illegal immigration, leaving the states to deal with the consequences of 11 to 20 million illegal immigrants residing in the United States, the number in Rhode Island being between 20,000 and 40,000, more than the population of 32 of Rhode Island’s 39 cities and towns; and
WHEREAS, the presence of significant numbers of people illegally residing in the State of Rhode Island creates a burden on the resources of state and local human services, law enforcement agencies, educational institutions and other governmental institutions and diminishes opportunities for citizens and legal immigrants in Rhode Island; and
WHEREAS, in 1996 Congress amended the Immigration and Nationality Act, 8 U.S.C. §1373(c), to allow government entities or officials to send to or receive from the Immigration and Naturalization Service information regarding the citizenship or immigration status, lawful or unlawful, of any individual and the federal government established the E-Verify program to help employers electronically verify the employment eligibility of new hires and the validity of their Social Security numbers; and
WHEREAS, the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act (IIRAIRA) added Section 287(g), performance of immigration officer functions by state officers and employees, to the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), and authorizes the
Executive Order 08-01
March 27, 2008
Page 2
Secretary of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security to enter into agreements with state and local law enforcement agencies, permitting designated officers to perform immigration law enforcement functions pursuant to a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA), provided that the local law enforcement officers received appropriate training and function under the supervision of sworn U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers; and
WHEREAS, law enforcement can more effectively combat criminal activity related to illegal immigration if federal, state and local authorities work on a cooperative basis.
NOW, THEREFORE, I, DONALD L. CARCIERI, by virtue of the authority vested in me as Governor of the State of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations do hereby order as follows:
1.
The Department of Administration shall register and use the federal government’s E-Verify program to electronically verify the employment eligibility of new hires in the Executive Branch and the validity of their Social Security numbers to ensure that all employees of the Executive Branch are legally eligible to be employed in the United States and take appropriate action against those that are not eligible for employment, consistent with federal and state law. For purposes of this Order, the Executive Branch of government is considered to be all agencies and departments in the Executive Branch, excluding the offices of general officers, said officers being the Department of Attorney General, Lieutenant Governor, Secretary of State, and General Treasurer.
2.
The Department of Administration shall require that all persons and businesses, including grantees, contractors and their subcontractors and vendors doing business with the State of Rhode Island also register with and utilize the services of the E-Verify program to ensure compliance with federal and state law.
3.
The Directors of each department and state agency in the Executive Branch shall attempt to notify any person whose identity was stolen or otherwise improperly used by any person in order receive any benefit, including but not limited to child care, health care, any government issued identification card, including driver’s license and non-driver’s license identification, welfare or employment.
4.
The Rhode Island State Police, pursuant to the authority set forth in Section 287(g) of IIRAIRA and INA, shall work to secure a MOA with ICE to receive training necessary to enable them to assist ICE personnel in the enforcement of federal immigration laws.
Executive Order 08-01
March 27, 2008
Page 3
5.
The Department of Corrections shall also work with ICE officials to secure an MOA that will define the scope of state correctional personnel authority to perform certain immigration law enforcement functions which shall be subject to the cross-supervision of ICE and permit certain correctional personnel to complete appropriate training and function under the supervision of sworn ICE officers to combat illegal immigration issues at the Adult Correctional Institution, consistent with federal and state law.
6.
It is urged that all law enforcement officials, including state and local law enforcement agencies take steps to support the enforcement of federal immigration laws by investigating and determining the immigration status of all non-citizens taken into custody, incarcerated, or under investigation for any crime and notifying federal authorities of all illegal immigrants discovered as a result of such investigations.
7.
The Parole Board and the Department of Corrections shall work cooperatively with ICE personnel to provide for the parole and deportation of criminal aliens.
8.
Nothing in this Executive Order shall be construed to supersede, contravene or conflict with any federal or state law or regulation or deny a person’s rights under the Rhode Island or United States Constitution and to this extent employees of the Executive Branch may act independently of this Executive Order in order to avoid such conflict or violation.
So Ordered:
Donald L. Carcieri
Dated: